Mike Kueber's Blog

July 27, 2010

Death knell for affirmative action?

The Republican Party of Texas has taken a lot of heat for some of the extreme positions it has taken in its 2010 platform, especially its position that homosexuality is deviant behavior that must not be recognized as an acceptable alternative lifestyle.  But their platform position on Affirmative Action is dead-on. 

  • Affirmative Action – Inasmuch as the Civil Rights Movement argued against using race as a factor in American life, affirmative action reintroduces race as a powerful force in American life. The Republican Party of Texas believes in equal opportunity for all American citizens without regard to race or gender. To that end, we oppose affirmative action because
    1. We believe it is simply racism disguised as a social value.
    2. We believe that policies that lower standards on the basis of race or gender create a disincentive to excellence and thereby encourage mediocrity.
    3. We believe that rights belong to people – not groups; therefore, we reject the notion of group-rights and policies that grant preferences based on race or gender. Policies of this type apply a blanket remedy before specific acts of discrimination are proven; thus, such policies compound one injustice with another.
    4. Affirmative action falsely casts those who advocate merit as racist.
    5. Affirmative action casts doubt on minority achievement making such achievement as seemingly unearned. We believe that true minority advancement will come from a demand for personal responsibility, accountability and competitive excellence.

Of course, the Republican Party position has been opposed by the liberal left because the left doesn’t think the playing field in America is level and they think a bit of government interference will make for more equal opportunity.

This debate has been going on for decades, ever since Kennedy and Johnson issued executive orders in the 60s requiring some forms of so-called affirmative action.  Conservative opponents called it reverse discrimination and have consistently challenged it on Equal Protection grounds.  In 1978, there was an important Supreme Court decision – Bd. of Regents v. Bakke – that approved affirmative action, but not quotas, in medical-school admissions.  Twenty-five years later, the Court looked at this matter again in Grutter v. Bollinger.  Although the Court in Grutter re-approved racial preferences, it felt such strong reservations about the concept that it stated the preferences must be limited in time and should not be around 25 years later.

Perhaps we won’t have to wait 25 years. 

This past Friday, there was an important op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal written by Senator James Webb, D-VA, titled “Diversity and the Myth of White Privilege,” and subtitled “America still owes a debt to its black citizens, but government programs to help all ‘people of color’ are unfair. They should end.”  http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703724104575379630952309408.html?mod=WSJ_article_related.  This is an important piece because Webb is a well-respected liberal Democrat and powerful African-American Congressman James Clyburn has said he agrees with Webb.    

Webb’s piece followed a similar NYTimes article that was published last month regarding diversity or affirmative action in France.  http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/01/world/europe/01ecoles.html?pagewanted=1.  The article reported that the French are trying to create more diversity in their best schools, but, “There is a serious question about how to measure diversity in a country where every citizen is presumed equal and there are no official statistics based on race, religion or ethnicity….  A goal cannot be called a ‘quota,’ which has an odor of the United States and affirmative action….  But the effort is being met with concerns from the grandes écoles, who fear it could dilute standards, and is stirring anger among the French at large, who fear it runs counter to a French ideal of a meritocracy blind to race, religion and ethnicity.”

Thus, we appear to have liberal Democrats, the French government, and the Republican Party of Texas speaking with the same voice regarding affirmative action.  Amazing.

1 Comment »

  1. […] UT, UT-Austin Last week, I posted a blog entry about the death knell for affirmative action.  https://mkueber001.wordpress.com/2010/07/27/death-knell-for-affirmative-action/.  The entry was prompted by a prominent Democratic senator concluding that the practice did more […]

    Pingback by Affirmative action at UT-Austin « Mike Kueber's Blog — August 4, 2010 @ 6:03 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: